One of the biggest decisions in a bathroom remodel is whether to keep a tub or switch to a walk-in shower. Here is how to think through the choice.
1. Consider daily use first
If your household rarely uses the tub, converting to a walk-in shower can free up space and improve daily function.
2. Resale value depends on bathroom count
Homes with only one tub in the entire house often benefit from keeping at least one, since future buyers may expect it.
3. Walk-in showers can improve accessibility
Curbless, zero-entry showers are easier and safer to use for people with mobility concerns, now or in the future.
4. Space requirements differ
A comfortable walk-in shower typically needs more square footage than a standard tub-shower combo, which can affect layout.
5. Glass enclosures affect style and cost
Frameless glass creates an open, modern look but costs more than a framed enclosure or shower curtain setup.
6. Tubs offer options too
Soaking tubs and freestanding tubs can be a design focal point if you want to keep bathing as an option.
7. Think about the whole hausehold
Consider who uses the bathroom daily, including children or family members who may still need a tub.
Trying to decide between a shower and a tub for your remodel? We are always happy to help.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a typical bathroom remodel cost in Southwest Florida?
Costs vary significantly based on size, finishes, and whether plumbing is being relocated. A licensed contractor can provide an accurate estimate after seeing your space and discussing your goals.
Does removing a tub hurt resale value?
It can, if your home would be left with no tub at all. If you have multiple bathrooms, converting one to a shower is usually not a concern.
Are walk-in showers more expensive than tubs?
It depends on size and finishes. A basic shower conversion can be comparable to tub replacement, while a custom, oversized shower with premium tile will cost more.
Can a walk-in shower be added later if I keep my tub now?
Yes, though it typically requires additional plumbing and tile work. It’s often more cost-effective to decide during your current remodel if you’re considering a future change.